metaphor-700Last week I talked about the essence of metaphor creation, that they are essential the collisions of ideas or things that don’t belong together.  We explored this through an exercise called Word Collision, which is essentially the “accidental” creation of metaphor through the random pairing of nouns and adjectives.  This week I’d like to be a little more purposeful and give you two guiding questions that drive and inform all good metaphor creation.

The trick is in identifying the connecting idea.  Here are the two questions you need to get to the heart of it:

  1. What characteristics does this idea have?
  2. What else has those characteristics?

Let’s see this in action.  I’m going to pick something to illustrate how the metaphors come tumbling out with just these two questions.  I’ve picked the police as my subject.  Now I ask myself, “what qualities do the the police have?”  and just start listing the fragments:

  • protect
  • corrupt
  • peace keepers
  • abuse
  • power
  • control

We’ll start there.  Now I ask myself, “what else has those characteristics?”  Just take one of the words to start.  I’ll take protect:

  • Guns protect
  • So do houses, buildings, and bomb shelters
  • Clothing protects, raincoats, sorrels, gloves.

Let’s see what we have:

The police are the guns of society

The police are the bomb shelters of the city

A raincoat of police

I kind of like that last one.  You can just see the police fanning out.  Let’s keep going.  Corrupt:

  • The Mob is corrupt
  • Dictatorships are corrupt
  • A computer virus corrupts a computer file.

The police are the mob of the city

The police are the dictators of society

A virus of police

Again, I like that last one.  It’s a bit abstract, (what exactly does a virus of police look like?) but it gives me the general impression of an out of control force working towards a bad end. Alright, one more.  Let’s take power:

  • Hurricanes have power
  • So do horses
  • Ferrari’s have power
  • The United States has power
  • Cannons, tanks, and explosions have power.

A hurricane of police

An explosion of police

The police are society’s cannons

Again, interesting.  I never would have thought to say, “a hurricane of police”, but I think it is a rich metaphor in that I can see them moving with the speed and ferocity of 100mph winds. See how many metaphors I’ve generated?  And that was just from three of our words.  There’s no limit to the number of ideas you can generate.  Now you try.  And by all means, drop me your favorites in the comments below.

  • Share/Bookmark
Related Posts
  • I Have This Dream Lyrics The entry to Michael Jackson's lyric writing contest that didn't make it in time.......
  • Super! Power! Cheesy and Sleazy Lyric Writing Stall One Saturday in Perth Western Australia Super! Power! set up a stall. They asked the general public to sit down and pick up a fluffy feather pen and write some song lyrics/poetry about what Super! Power! means to them. One day these words are destined to be integrated into......
  • Shangri-la OP [English fandub] (Dreambelieva Version) Song: Kimi Shinitamou Koto Nakare Original artist: May'n Dreambelieva strikes again, with her spontaneous lyric writing and terrifying singing Run while you can~ bwahahha XD I tried my best to match the translation as close as possible, but improvising was unavoidable XD ------------------------------------------------------------ You Shall Not Die English lyric......
Related Websites
  • I'll Be Waiting Preface It all started when I joined the spyworld when I was 16. I was shortlisted as a candidate after a 10 day camp. All of us thought it was just an outdoor camp that was very different from the other courses. So yeah, a lady posed as a principal......
  • Save Time, Money and Space in Over 80 Ways If you're looking for handy gadgets, tools and various items that can save you time, money or space (or all three!) this list of more than 80 top products is just what you need. Everyone's got saving money on their minds these days. Some of us are always looking to......
  • Shadow Inventory Following on the discussion from yesterday, there's another topic you're going to start hearing more about soon: shadow inventory. What is Shadow Inventory? Before we talk about shadow inventory, we have to first figure out what inventory is. Inventory in this case in the number of homes currently for sale......
Instant Weekly Roundup - Free WordPress Plugin
  • Share/Bookmark
Related Posts
  • Promoting Music Online By Heather McDonald of musicians.about.com: Online music promotion - you know you need to do it, but the number of options available to get the job done can be down right overwhelming. This how-to guide for promoting music online will walk you through the steps you need to follow......
  • The Best Internet Radio Stations: Jango.com, Finetune, Slacker, Imeem, Mog, Last.fm and Pandora It's intimidating trying to find the best internet radio stations, right? Whether you're bored at work or simply a couch potato at home, there is now the mysterious world of internet radio meets social networking. Yup, you've heard about all this nonsense with "friend recommendations" and "streaming playlists", yea? Have......
  • Best way to listen to music. Internet radio. This video shows how to get free internet radio. Programs needed: Winamp Free Version (www.winamp.com) Shoutcast Radio listings (http Free. Only need to go there one time. Bookmark your stations. You can get free music on your computer. Legally. Usually it is very high-quality (if you have decent speakers).......
Related Websites
  • A Beautiful Interview Ceri Shaw suggested me an interview from our friends at Americymru. So here's this beautiful interview with Dr. Karl Jenkins (I include also the link to their ticket giveaway competition for his performance at Carnegie Hall NY on March 6th 2010). A Beautiful Interview Dr. Karl Jenkins is Britain's greatest......
  • Banana Bread Recipe I love banana bread! I like to use bananas that are very ripe with lots of brown splotches; they give a sweeter flavor. However, the bananas in my house are usually eaten before this stage. Not the case this week! I noticed the bananas in the fruit bowl were......
  • Going on Vacation, but the Writing Continues I'm going on my honeymoon this week and next. Since I will be outside the country, I will likely have a limited Internet connection. This means that I might be a little slow approving comments. I may also be blogging, but even if I can't, have no fear - there......

“Against the canvas of the night,

Appears a curious celestial phenomenon…”

-Mos Def,  Astronomy (8th Light)

4233-night-sky-at-25-degree



Is the night sky really canvas?  No.  When you read this line do you suddenly see the sky as a thick black material arching above you?  I do.  This is the power of metaphor.  Metaphors are mainstays of good lyric writing and creative writing as well.  In their simplest sense, metaphors are the collisions of ideas or things that don’t belong together.  Metaphors must not be a physical reality. Like we said, the night sky isn’t literally canvas, it’s just a bunch of atmosphere without sunlight.  But what if you look up in the sky and see, as Mos Def probably did, something thick and black with stars almost painted on it?  Now the sky can seem like a canvas against which curious celestial phenomenon appear.

Humans are endlessly capable of weaving seemingly unconnected ideas into something with meaning.  Metaphors are perhaps the greatest example of this.  Let’s take a look at some ways to generate metaphors.

The Connecting Idea

Metaphors work and often arise from one simple principle:

Something has a quality, in the case of  “the night” it could be thickness, or blackness, or even the fact that the sky can look like a surface. Now, something else shares one or more of those qualities, in this case it’s canvas. Thickness, blackness or surface all connect “the night” to “canvas”.  They are the connecting idea.  Metaphors that couple two nouns like this are called expressed identity.

Expressed identity metaphors come in three flavors:

  1. One is “X is Y”  (as in the night is canvas)
  2. Another is “The X of Y” (like the above example, the canvas of night)
  3. The last is “X’s Y” (as in night’s canvas)



Another kind of metaphor is called a verbal metaphor.  These involve conflict between the verb and its subject.  His cut was crying blood. Cuts don’t really cry, but by taking one characteristic of wounds, that they bead up and drip, and using an unusual verb that also describes this phenomenon, crying, we have created a collision.  The connecting idea in this case is beads up and drips.  In one case it’s blood and in another case it’s tears, but both bead up and drip.


The last kind of metaphor is called a qualifying metaphor.  In this kind adjectives qualify nouns and adverbs qualify verbs.  Examples of this could be a furious storm or laughing blindly. Storms don’t have emotions nor can laughter be blind but qualifying metaphors use an unrelated adjective or adverb to infuse some new meaning into a noun or verb.

Creating Your Own Metaphors With Word Collisions

Alright, now you’re going to create your own metaphors using word collisions.  For the first part of this take a piece of paper and write 5 adjectives on one side and 5 nouns on another.

Picture 3

Now take your lists and start cramming the words together and see which combinations are interesting.  Remember, metaphors must not be able to be real.  Swollen eyes is not a metaphor because someone can actually have swollen eyes.  Swollen railroad is a metaphor because railroads can’t really be swollen.

Picture 4

Now mix them up for a second round.

Picture 5

You should be able to start to see some real possibilities for your metaphors.  I could see how both my railroad metaphors could lend themselves to a lyric about how the railroads “gobbled up” the countryside and brought a whole new level of traffic to previously untouched wilderness.  Or how much that crass, crotchety lawn mower bothered me the other day while I tried to nap.  All from the blind plucking of words out of the air.  Word collisions yield some surprising results.  Give them a try and leave me a comment with some of your favorites!

  • Share/Bookmark
Related Posts
  • Lyric Writing Tips Showing How To Use Stability In Your Songs This test will show you powerful lyric writing tips to use song stability to your advantage. This includes writing the music and lyric content. Think about what your intention is in your songs. Do you want a stable or unstable song and how and where are you building and releasing......
  • How to write a wonderful lyric – For beginners Have you ever tried to write a song? While this actually happens to some lyricists and songwriters, the chances are slim for a person to reach that height of success. But, what the heck! If you have an idea for a song, you might as well write it down and......
  • Shangri-la OP [English fandub] (Dreambelieva Version) Song: Kimi Shinitamou Koto Nakare Original artist: May'n Dreambelieva strikes again, with her spontaneous lyric writing and terrifying singing Run while you can~ bwahahha XD I tried my best to match the translation as close as possible, but improvising was unavoidable XD ------------------------------------------------------------ You Shall Not Die English lyric......
Related Websites
  • Butterfly Hardfull Table Tennis Racket Case II (White) User Reviews Send this to a friend Butterfly Hardfull Table Tennis Racket Case II (White) Manufacturer: Butterfly Customer Rating: List Price: $35.99 Sale Price: $29.99 Availibility: Usually ships in 2-3 business days Buy Now Product Description Sleek racket case with hard outer shell. Provides excellent protection for your racket.......
  • Overcome writer’s block: Understanding the Yin and Yang nature of the creative process I have never done writing for a living yet. My writing has always been mostly for study or passion. Yet even though I haven’t been under the pressure of having my monthly income depending on the flow and quality of my writing as any paid writer would, my own......
  • How to Avoid the Dangers in Foreign Coin Collecting Coin collecting is considered by many to be one of the risk free hobbies. You purchase coins at a good rate, hold on to them for a while and then sell them for a huge return. The problem is that it does not always work out this way. As coin......